
This article is a brief refresher on the basics of New York’s one-action rule. Following an event of default, typical commercial real estate loan documents give the lender the right to pursue alternative remedies simultaneously, or in any order it chooses. For example, if a borrower is in default on a mortgage loan beyond any applicable notice and cure periods, the mortgage usually provides the lender the right to foreclose its mortgage while simultaneously suing on the note or, if applicable, a guaranty. However, every lender needs to be aware that some states have enacted so-called “one-action rules” which, in many circumstances, restrict a lender’s right to simultaneously pursue multiple legal actions to recover the debt. We would note that one-action rules can vary greatly from state to state, and this article specifically focuses on New York’s application of the rule.